Twelve Pictures on the Floor
I spent most of a winter making pictures at the feed store out on the county road, and at the end of it I had four hundred frames and about sixty that were good. I printed the sixty small, laid them out on the living room floor, and looked at them for a week, and what I understood at the end of that week was that I did not have a photo essay. I had sixty good pictures of a feed store, which is a different and much less interesting thing.
The distinction took me years to feel rather than merely know. A set of good pictures is an inventory. An essay is an argument. The pictures in an essay are not there because they are the best ones. They are there because they do a job, and some of the best ones do no job at all.
What Makes It an Essay Instead of a Set
An essay has a claim. Not a caption or a topic, a claim — something you could say in a flat sentence, and that the pictures then demonstrate without ever saying.
My feed store pile had no claim. It had a subject. When I finally found the sentence, it was something like: this business runs on knowledge that lives in one man’s head and is not written down anywhere. The moment I had that, the edit did itself. Every frame that showed him knowing something — reading a bag, judging a bad sack by weight, answering a question without looking up — became necessary. Every frame that was merely a nice interior fell out, including three I loved.
You almost never have the claim at the start. You shoot, and the claim emerges from the material, and then you go back and shoot the four frames you now need and did not know to make. That second trip is the part most people skip, and it is the difference between a set and a piece of work.
How Many Frames
Fewer than you want. My working range is eight to sixteen. Under eight and it usually reads as a fragment. Over twenty and the viewer stops looking and starts scrolling, and the weakest frame drags everything toward it.
The number is not arbitrary either. It comes out of how the thing will be seen. A sequence on a screen has to survive a viewer who is moving quickly, so it wants to be short and to have a strong second frame. A sequence in a print folder can run longer because the physical act of turning slows people down.
Twelve is where I land most often. It is enough to establish, develop, complicate, and close, and it is short enough that I am forced to cut things that are merely good.
Sequencing, Which Is Where the Work Actually Is
The first frame
The first frame sets the terms. It tells the viewer where they are, roughly what kind of looking is required, and whether this is going to be about a place or a person. I almost never open with the strongest picture, because the strongest picture usually answers too much. I open with the one that raises the question.
The middle
The middle is where sequences fail. The common failure is monotony of scale — six medium shots in a row, all made from about the same distance, all equally weighted. The viewer gets tired without knowing why.
- Vary the distance deliberately. Wide, then close, then medium. The rhythm of near and far is what carries a viewer through, and it works even when they are not conscious of it.
- Let two frames talk to each other. Facing pairs that rhyme — a shape repeated, a gesture answered — make the viewer do a small amount of work, and a viewer who is working is a viewer who is present.
- Put a quiet frame after a loud one. An empty room after a face. The quiet frame is where the previous picture actually lands, and sequences without any rest read as shouting.
- Do not repeat information. If two frames tell the viewer the same fact, one of them is decoration no matter how good it is. This is the rule that kills my favorites most often.
The last frame
The closer should not resolve everything. My best endings tend to be slightly open — a door, a road, somebody leaving, a thing put away. If the final picture wraps it up neatly, the viewer files the whole essay away and forgets it before dinner.
Editing Your Own Work Down
Cutting your own pictures is the hardest single skill in photography and nothing about it gets easier with practice. What gets easier is recognizing the specific ways you lie to yourself.
I know my lies now. I overvalue a picture that was difficult to get, because I remember standing in the cold for it. I overvalue the one that is technically perfect. I overvalue the first good frame I made on a project, because it was the one that convinced me there was something there. None of those reasons are visible in the picture, and none of them mean anything to a viewer.
So I use mechanical tricks to get around my own memory. I print small and lay everything out flat, because a screen shows one picture at a time and a floor shows relationships. I leave it for a week, because time is the only thing that reliably drains the sentiment out of a frame. I make the sequence, then remove the picture I would least want to lose and look again — if it still works, that picture was carrying my ego rather than the essay.
And I show it to one person who does not photograph. Not for a critique. I watch their eyes. Wherever they slow down or go back is where the sequence is confused, and I have never had one of them be wrong about that.
The Feed Store, Cut Down
Sixty went to eleven. It opens with the parking lot at seven in the morning, empty, because the essay is about knowledge and I wanted to start before any of it is on display. Then his hands. Then two customers, then the wall where the prices are written in grease pencil, then the long middle where he does his job. It ends with the light off and the door closed from inside.
Three of my favorite pictures from that winter are not in it. One is the best photograph I made all year. It is a beautiful frame about a beam of light and it has nothing to do with what the essay says, and every time I put it back in, the sequence goes slack around it.
It lives in a folder by itself, and that is what it is for. A good picture that does not belong in a piece of work has not failed. It is just a good picture, on its own, which is what most photographs are and what most photographs should be allowed to be.
Why Bother Making Essays at All
Because a single photograph can only ever be a moment, and there are things about a town that are not moments. The reason a business survives. What a job actually consists of. How a place changes across a season. Those are arguments, and arguments need more than one frame and fewer than a hundred.
The work of finding which eleven is not glamorous and does not look like photography. It looks like a man sitting on the floor for a week moving small prints around. That week is where the meaning gets made, and I have never once had it happen out on the job with a camera in my hands.