The Question Nobody Asks Out Loud
I was on the square photographing the way light came off the wet brick after a storm, and a boy of about seven ran through the frame chasing a dog. It was, briefly, a wonderful picture. His mother was fifteen feet away watching me and I watched her decide whether to be concerned.
That is the whole subject, right there. Not the law, which is fairly permissive, and not photographic history, which is full of children in public. The subject is a woman doing arithmetic about a stranger with a camera near her kid, and what I do in the next four seconds.
I lowered the camera, turned, and said something ordinary about the storm. She relaxed. I never made the picture. I have thought about that trade a lot, and I still think I got the better end of it.
What Is Legal Is Not the Question
In Tennessee, in a public place, I can photograph what I can see, including children, and I do not need permission. That is the answer to the legal question and it is nearly useless to me.
Because I do not work here once. I work here for years. I am going to see that woman at the grocery store, and her kid is going to be in the marching band that I photograph in the fall, and her opinion of me is a working condition. A photographer in a town of this size operates on a permission that is granted informally, continuously, and can be withdrawn all at once.
So the real standard is not what I am allowed to do. It is whether the picture is worth what it costs in trust, and the honest answer is usually no.
The Difference Context Makes
Where a camera is expected
At the Fair on the Square, at a parade, at a Dragons game, at a school event, a camera is part of the furniture. Parents are photographing. The paper is there. A child in that setting is in a public, celebratory, documented situation, and photographing them is close to unremarkable. Nobody is alarmed and nobody should be.
Where it is not
A kid alone at a bus stop. A child in a yard. Two children on a sidewalk with no adult in sight. A playground on a weekday. Same town, same street, completely different act. The picture may be lovely and the situation reads as surveillance, and the reading is what people actually experience.
I use a simple test that has never failed me. If I imagine the child’s parent looking over my shoulder at the moment I press the shutter, does the situation explain itself instantly, or would I have to talk my way out of it? If I would have to explain, I do not take it. Not because it is wrong in principle, but because a picture that requires a defense is not worth making in a place I intend to keep living in.
Asking, and What Asking Actually Does
People assume asking is a formality that ruins the moment. Mostly it is not, because I am rarely asking for the candid frame I already lost. I am asking for the next twenty minutes.
- I ask the adult first, then the child. The parent gives permission, but the kid gives consent, and they are different things. A nine-year-old who says no gets a no from me even when the mother has said yes. It costs me a picture and it teaches the child that a camera can be refused, which I consider a genuinely good thing to teach.
- I say what it is for, in one sentence. Not a pitch. Something like: I photograph the town, this might go on my site or nowhere at all, and I will send you the file. Vagueness is what makes people nervous, not cameras.
- I show them the back of the camera. Immediately, on the spot. It converts an unknown into a known, and it has ended more suspicion than any explanation I have ever given.
- I take the no cleanly. No persuading, no one more, no wounded look. The way you accept a refusal is the reputation you build, and it travels much further and faster than any photograph.
When I Do Not Photograph Children at All
There are frames I will not make regardless of who says yes. A child crying or in distress, unless a parent has specifically asked me to document something. A child who is hurt. Anything that would embarrass a fourteen-year-old version of that same person. Anything where the child is the only identifiable subject and I have no relationship with the family at all.
I also think hard about publishing separately from shooting. Those are two decisions and I used to treat them as one. I can make a picture, keep it, show it to the family, and never put it online. A good number of my favorite frames of children live exactly there, and I am at peace with it. The internet is a strange, permanent, searchable place, and a seven-year-old cannot consent to being in it at thirty.
Being a Photographer People Trust
Most of this is not about ethics in the abstract. It is about being legible. Suspicion is almost always a failure of information, and a photographer can supply information cheaply.
I work in the open. I do not use a long lens on people at close range, because a 300 on a sidewalk looks like exactly what it looks like. I do not shoot from a car. I stand where I can be seen, I make eye contact, I say hello first. When somebody looks at me a beat too long, I close the distance and introduce myself rather than pretending not to notice, and the situation nearly always ends in a conversation.
I also deliver. Over fifteen years I have emailed a lot of files to a lot of parents for nothing, and the practical result is that when I show up at the fall festival now, people know who I am. That is not a marketing strategy. It is the accumulated effect of being the same person every time, and it has made the work possible in a way that no amount of technique would have.
The Frames I Gave Up
I keep a mental list of the good ones I did not take. The boy and the dog on the wet brick. Two girls on the steps of the depot in November light that I will not see again. A kid asleep against a fence at the end of a long day at the fair, which would have been the best thing I made that year.
I am not going to pretend that costs nothing. It costs real pictures, and anyone who tells you an ethical practice is free has not given up much. But I have been photographing this town for a long time, and the thing that lets me keep doing it is not any single frame. It is that a couple of thousand people here have decided, correctly, that I am not a problem.
That is worth more than the boy and the dog. I still think about the boy and the dog.