Getting There Before It Is Anything
I show up to the Fair on the Square about two hours before it opens, which means I am on the square at roughly the same time as the people setting up the tents. Nothing is happening. That is the point.
Everybody photographs the event. Very few people photograph the hour when a field of empty booths turns into a fair, and that hour is where I get a third of what I keep. The light is better, the crowd has not arrived to block anything, and the people working are doing real work with their hands rather than standing behind a table smiling.
Arriving early also does something that has nothing to do with pictures. By the time it starts, I have already talked to a dozen people. I am not a stranger with a camera moving through the crowd. I am the guy who was here at seven, and every one of those small conversations makes the next four hours easier.
The Two Hours That Matter
Every event I have ever photographed has a real duration of about two hours inside a nominal duration of eight. The trick is knowing which two, and it is different for each kind of event.
A parade
The two hours are the forty minutes before it steps off and the first twenty minutes of the route. Staging is where the pictures are — kids adjusting uniforms, a horse being calmed, somebody fixing a float with duct tape. Once it is moving, it becomes a procession, and a procession is visually the same for its entire length.
A high school game
Not the game. Warmups, the walk out, the sideline in the fourth quarter, and the ten minutes after the final whistle. I have photographed a lot of football at Dragons games and almost nothing I keep is a play. It is a boy taking his helmet off, a coach with his hands on his knees, parents in the stands in the cold.
A festival
Setup, and then the last ninety minutes before it ends, when everyone is tired, the light is long, and the performing has stopped. The middle of the day is bright, flat, crowded, and produces almost nothing.
Knowing this has changed my stamina more than anything else. I used to shoot the whole thing and come home with two thousand frames and a headache. Now I work hard for two hours, walk around with the camera down for four, and work hard again at the end.
Working a Crowd Without Becoming the Story
The failure mode at an event is that the photographer becomes an event. You see it constantly — somebody crouching in the middle of an aisle, backing into people, holding a camera over a crowd on a monopod, making everyone in a thirty-foot radius aware that they are being photographed. Every picture that person takes afterward has a subject who knows.
- Move at the speed of the crowd. If everyone is strolling and I am darting, I am a disturbance. Matching the pace of the people around me makes me close to invisible within about ten minutes.
- Pick a spot and let the event come to me. Standing still at a good corner for fifteen minutes produces more than fifteen minutes of hunting. People stop registering somebody who has not moved, and the frame builds itself over and over in front of you.
- Stay off the ground unless it earns something. Crouching and lying down draw enormous attention at an event. I do it maybe twice a day, and only when the picture genuinely requires the low angle rather than because low angles feel dynamic.
- One camera, one lens. Changing lenses in a crowd takes me out of the moment, makes me look like equipment, and I have never once solved a real problem by switching. A 35 handles almost the entire day.
I also stopped wearing anything that reads as press. No vest, no second body on a strap, no lanyard. The more I look like a man at a fair who happens to have a camera, the more the fair behaves like a fair.
The Light an Event Gives You
Nobody schedules a festival for a photographer. The fair runs through the middle of the day in September, which in this part of Tennessee means overhead sun, deep eye sockets, and a white sky. For years I fought that light and lost.
What I do now is let it decide where I stand. Under the tents there is a soft sideways light coming in off the pavement that is better than anything available out in the open, and it happens to be exactly where the people doing the work are. The shade line along the west side of the buildings moves across the square all afternoon and hands me an even light with a bright street behind it.
None of that is clever. It is knowing one place well enough to know where the good light hides at two in the afternoon, which is the only real advantage of photographing the same town year after year.
What You Owe the People in the Pictures
An event is a public occasion and I can legally photograph nearly everything at one. That settles almost nothing about what I should do with the results.
My rules are simple and I have not changed them in a decade. I do not publish a picture that makes an identifiable person look foolish, even when it is the funniest frame of the day. Somebody with a mouth full of food, somebody mid-blink, somebody whose clothing has failed them. That picture might get shared a hundred times, and the person in it lives four miles from me and has to go to work on Monday.
I do not publish an obviously private moment that happened to occur in public — an argument, a crying child, a family in an unguarded state that is not really about the event at all.
And I say yes when somebody asks me to take one down. Immediately, without asking why. It happens perhaps once a year and it has never cost me anything that mattered.
Giving the Pictures Back
The other half of the obligation is more pleasant. After a big event I spend an evening sending files to people. The woman running the pottery booth, the band director, the family whose kid was on the fire truck. Full size, no watermark, no charge, no strings.
This is the single most useful thing I do as a photographer in this town, and it took me too long to start. It turns the transaction around. I took something at the event — their image, their moment — and giving something back closes the loop. Practically speaking, it is also why I can walk up to almost any booth at the fair now and be greeted rather than tolerated.
The one thing I am careful about is not promising more than I will deliver. If I say I will send it, I send it that week. A photographer who takes your picture, says he will email it, and never does is worse for the profession than one who never asked.
What I Actually Keep
From a full day at the fair, I keep maybe twenty frames, and the pattern in them is consistent enough that it has become a kind of instruction to myself. Very few are of the main attraction. Almost none are wide shots of a crowd, which look like every other crowd anywhere.
What survives is edges and labor. The person running the thing rather than the thing. A kid waiting. Two friends talking with their backs to the parade. Somebody eating in the shade behind a booth. The break-down at the end, when the square goes back to being a square.
An event is easy to photograph and hard to photograph well, precisely because there is so much happening that any frame feels productive. The discipline is remembering that a picture of a busy scene is not the same as a picture of something, and that the day the town gathers is mostly interesting for what it shows about the town on all the other days.