She asked me to teach her, and I did it badly
A friend of mine bought a camera last spring and asked if I would show her how to use it. I said yes immediately, because being asked is flattering, and then I spent about six weeks being fairly useless to her before I figured out what she was actually asking for.
What I did at first was what everybody does. I explained the controls. I drew the triangle of settings on the back of a receipt. I told her about the relationship between the three things and I could see her writing it down and I could see that none of it was landing anywhere that mattered. She learned it, dutifully, the way you learn the parts of a cell for a test. Her pictures did not change at all.
The problem was that she had not asked how the camera works. She had asked, in the way people actually ask things, why her pictures did not look like the thing she had seen. That is a completely different question and I answered the wrong one for a month and a half.
What was actually wrong with her pictures
Nothing technical. That was the thing. They were correctly exposed and adequately sharp and they were of the right subjects. She would photograph her daughter, or the dogwood in her yard, or a table at a restaurant, and each picture was a competent record of a thing that existed.
What was missing was any indication of why she had stopped. Every frame was made from wherever she happened to be standing, at whatever distance she happened to be, containing everything that happened to be in front of her. The subject was in there somewhere, along with six other things, all of them the same size and the same importance.
I finally said something like: I can tell what you photographed but I cannot tell what you looked at. She said that was exactly the problem, and she looked relieved that somebody had finally named it, and I felt bad about the receipt with the triangle on it.
The first thing that helped
What worked, eventually, was not an explanation. It was a question I started asking every time she showed me a frame.
What made you stop?
Not what is this a picture of. What made you stop. She would look at it for a second and say something like, the light on the fence, or her hands, or the way the sign was crooked. And then I would ask the follow-up, which is the whole thing: is that the biggest thing in the frame?
It never was. It was a small thing off to the side, surrounded by a lot of material she had never consciously decided to include. Once she started noticing that gap — between the reason and the picture — she began closing it on her own, without me telling her a single thing about composition. She moved closer. She turned slightly. She waited for the person to move out of the left side.
I had spent six weeks trying to give her a set of rules and what she needed was one question she could ask herself in the moment. The rules would have been mine. The question was hers to answer.
The walk where it came apart, and then together
We went out one Saturday morning on the streets around the square, which I have photographed several hundred times and she had never photographed at all, and it was instructive in ways I did not enjoy.
For the first forty minutes she found nothing. Genuinely nothing. She kept looking at me to see where I was pointing, and I kept trying not to point, and it was awkward for both of us. At one point she said, with some frustration, that she did not understand how I was seeing anything, that the street just looked like a street.
So I stopped and described, out loud, everything I was noticing on one block. The shadow of the awning stopping exactly at the curb. A window with a hand-lettered sign that had been there so long the tape had gone brown. Two chairs pulled up to each other on the sidewalk with nobody in them. The gap between two buildings where you can see a whole other street. It took maybe three minutes and I felt ridiculous doing it.
It was the single most useful three minutes of the entire thing. Not because my observations were good, but because she had assumed seeing was instantaneous and silent, a thing that either happened to you or did not. Hearing it as a slow, boring, spoken-aloud list broke the spell. About ten minutes later she stopped in front of a doorway and said, out loud, the paint on this is three different colors, and made a picture of it, and it was hers and not mine.
The assignments that worked and the ones that did not
I tried a number of exercises on her. Some were useful and some were the kind of thing that sounds good and teaches nothing.
- One block, thirty minutes, twenty frames. This worked immediately. Constraint forces attention. When you cannot leave, you start looking down and up.
- Photograph the same object at three distances. Worked. It made the choice of distance visible as a choice rather than an accident.
- Photograph only what is in shadow for an hour. Worked well, better than I expected, because it made light into a subject instead of a condition.
- Photograph ten things you find ugly. This did not work. It produced a kind of ironic distance that was not honest to how she sees, and the pictures were mean in a way that was not her.
The pattern is clear enough in hindsight. The exercises that worked reduced the field of choice so she could pay attention to something. The one that failed asked her to adopt an attitude, and attitude cannot be assigned.
What she taught me by not knowing anything
This is the part I did not anticipate. Teaching her cost me some of my own automatic habits, and that turned out to be worth more than whatever I gave her.
She kept photographing things I had stopped seeing. The square has a set of planters that I consider visual furniture, and she made a picture looking straight down into one of them that I have thought about since. She has no history with this town and therefore no accumulated boredom about it, and boredom is the real enemy in a place you have lived a long time. I have thirty ready-made photographs of the square in my head and I default to them, and she had none, so she found something else.
She also asked why constantly, and I could not answer half of it. Why do you always work from that side of the street. I did not know. Why do you never photograph anything at eye level from far away. No good reason, apparently. Being made to justify habits out loud revealed that a fair number of them are not decisions, they are ruts.
What I would say to the next person
If somebody asks me this again, I am going to skip the receipt with the triangle on it entirely for the first month.
I would start with the question. What made you stop. Ask it of every frame, out loud, until it becomes automatic. It is the entire discipline compressed into four words, and everything else — framing, distance, timing, light — falls out of it as a consequence.
Then I would do the talking-out-loud walk early instead of an hour in, because the biggest obstacle for a beginner is not skill, it is the belief that people who see things are doing something mysterious. They are not. They are looking longer and naming what they find, and both of those are learnable.
The technical part can wait, and when it comes it will come with a reason attached, which is the only way any of it sticks. She asked me about depth of field herself, eventually, about eight weeks in, because she wanted the fence behind her daughter to stop competing. She had a problem and the setting was the answer to it. That took four minutes to explain and she has never forgotten it, which is more than I can say for the receipt.