An inventory of frames that do not exist
I keep a mental list of pictures I did not make. It is not a long list — maybe fifteen entries after all these years — but it is durable in a way that my actual archive is not. I can describe every item on it in detail. I cannot describe half the photographs on my own wall without going to look.
That asymmetry has bothered me enough that I finally sat down and wrote the list out, which I recommend, and which was more revealing than I expected. Written down, the missing pictures sorted themselves into categories almost immediately, and the categories are really categories of my own behavior.
The three I think about most
The first is a man on a bench outside the post office in the middle of a January afternoon, feeding pieces of a sandwich to a dog that was clearly not his — it kept looking back down the sidewalk at somebody. The light was flat and gray and would have been perfect for it. I had a camera. I walked past, decided it would be intrusive, got to my car, sat there for two minutes, went back, and the bench was empty. That was four years ago and I can still see the angle I wanted.
The second is my grandmother’s hands on the arms of a particular chair. I had years to make that picture. I thought about it a number of times and did not do it, because it felt like a cliche, and because taking it would have meant admitting to myself why I wanted it. The chair is in my house now. The hands are the picture I do not have.
The third is smaller and stranger. A rainstorm two summers ago, and the water coming off a flat commercial roof in a single sheet, hitting the pavement, throwing up a wall of spray with the sun already coming back out behind it. I was driving. There was nowhere to stop. I told myself it would happen again. In two years, it has not happened again.
Sorting the reasons
When I looked at the whole list, every entry came down to one of four reasons, and they are not equally forgivable.
- Fear of the person. I did not want to be seen, or refused, or thought badly of.
- Genuine consideration. Taking it would have cost somebody something real.
- Logistics. I was driving, I was carrying something, the light changed, I had no camera.
- Laziness dressed up as one of the other three.
The fourth is the largest category and it took me a while to admit it. Laziness in this context does not feel like laziness. It feels like discretion, or good manners, or a reasonable assessment that it is not worth the trouble. What it actually is: I did not want to change what I was doing. Stopping the car, turning around, crossing the street, opening the bag — each of those is a small interruption, and I talk myself out of small interruptions constantly and then dress the decision in something more flattering.
The man with the sandwich is in that category, if I am honest with myself. I told myself it was intrusion. But I went back, which means I did not really believe that. I was slow because going back felt awkward, and the awkwardness was about me.
The regrets that are legitimate
Not all of them are failures of nerve, and I want to be fair to myself about which ones were real constraints.
Some pictures genuinely required something I did not have. The rainstorm needed a shoulder to pull onto and there was not one. A funeral I attended a few years ago had two or three moments I saw clearly and would never have photographed, because I was there as a person and not as a photographer, and I would make that choice again every time. That is not a missed picture, that is a correct priority, and putting it on the list at all is a kind of vanity.
There is a real difference between a picture I failed to take and a picture I chose not to take. The first is a skill problem. The second is a values problem, and mine are mostly where I want them. I have deleted three entries off the list since writing it out, because on inspection they were not regrets at all — they were me being briefly annoyed that being a decent person has costs.
The ones I am glad I let go
There is a category I did not expect: pictures I am actively relieved not to have.
A few years ago a neighbor two streets over had a bad afternoon in his front yard, the kind involving a tow truck and raised voices, and half the block found a reason to be outside. It was, in a cold way, a good scene — gesture, light, a clear narrative. I had the camera in the car. I did not get it out, and I have never once wished I had.
What that taught me is that the impulse to photograph is not automatically worth honoring. It is just an impulse. It shows up in response to visual interest and has no opinions about anything else. Part of learning to photograph a place where you actually live is learning that you will keep living here afterward, and that the people in your frames buy groceries at the same store you do.
Someone passing through can take that picture. I cannot, and the reason is not cowardice. It is that my relationship to this town is the thing that makes any of my pictures of it worth anything, and there is a version of aggression that would spend that down for a single good frame.
How I have tried to move faster
For the ones that are just slowness, I have made some practical changes, and a couple of them have worked.
The biggest is that the camera does not live in a bag anymore. A bag has a zipper and the zipper is the whole problem. Somewhere in the two seconds it takes to open a zipper, I reconsider. So the camera sits on the passenger seat or hangs at my side, already set to something roughly workable, and the number of frames I have made in the last year that I would previously have talked myself out of is not small.
The second is a rule about turning around. If I have driven past something and I am still thinking about it thirty seconds later, I turn around. No further deliberation. It has cost me maybe forty minutes total over a year and it has given me four pictures I care about, one of which is among my favorites.
The third is a phrase I use on myself when I hesitate near a person: ask, do not decide for them. I have been assuming refusal on behalf of strangers for years. When I actually ask, most people say yes, and the ones who say no say it lightly and we both go on with our day.
Keeping the list
I have kept writing the list down and I intend to keep it going, because it turns out to be the most useful record I have. My archive tells me what I am capable of on a good day. The list tells me exactly where I stop, which is the more actionable information.
What I notice is that the entries have been changing character. The old ones are almost all about nerve. The recent ones are almost all logistics — wrong place, no camera, moving too fast in a car. That is not nothing. That looks like a person who fixed one problem and now has a different, smaller one.
And I have made peace, more or less, with the fact that some of these will never be resolved. The hands on the chair are gone. Nothing will bring them back and no amount of being braver now recovers them. What the list does is make sure the next one is not lost the same way, which is the only useful thing regret has ever done for anyone.