The street I stopped seeing
I have lived on the same street for fifteen years, and for most of that time I never photographed it. Not once seriously. I carried a camera down it several thousand times on my way to somewhere more interesting, and the street was simply the corridor I passed through to reach the pictures. It was the thing between my front door and the work. I would drive forty minutes for a field I had heard about and walk past four hundred feet of sidewalk without lifting my eyes off the middle distance.
What finally turned me around was an ordinary evening in late August, the kind of heat that stands in the road like a person. I came home from a wasted afternoon somewhere else, got out of the car with nothing, and noticed that the light coming through the neighbor’s hedge had cut the driveway into two temperatures. I had seen that hedge every day for fifteen years. I had never once seen the light do that, or rather I had seen it a thousand times and never registered it as information. I went inside, came back out, and made four frames that were not good. But something had been switched on.
What familiarity does to the eye
There is a mechanism in us that stops looking at what it already knows. It is a good mechanism. If I truly perceived my own kitchen every morning I would never get out of it. The brain builds a shorthand, a rough sketch it can substitute for the real thing, and after fifteen years my street had become a sketch: mailbox, oak, driveway, brick, oak, mailbox, corner. I could have drawn it from memory in thirty seconds and the drawing would have been wrong in every particular.
That is the strange trap of photographing where you live. You are not starting from zero, which sounds like an advantage and is not. You are starting from a confident, worn-down, badly compressed version of the place, and the first work is to demolish it. A stranger arriving on my street would make better pictures on day one than I made in year fifteen, because the stranger has no sketch to fight. What the stranger would miss, and what I eventually got, is everything the sketch was covering up.
So the project became an act of subtraction rather than discovery. I was not looking for something new on the street. I was trying to stop supplying my own answers before the street had finished the sentence.
Beginning with the mailboxes
I gave myself the dullest possible assignment because I did not trust my taste at that point. I photographed every mailbox on the street, one at a time, in order, over about three weeks. Nine mailboxes. I was not trying to make a typology or a series. I just needed a reason to stand in front of things I had decided were not worth standing in front of.
The mailboxes turned out to be an education. One of them leans, and has leaned for years, and the lean is held up by a length of gray tape that has been replaced at least twice because the layers are different colors. One has a number painted by a child, the six a little larger than the others and slightly higher on the wood, and I have known the family for a decade and never noticed. One is brand new and standing perfectly straight and looks, in a photograph, more temporary than the leaning one.
None of those nine frames is going anywhere. But by the end of them I could no longer walk to the corner without seeing. The assignment was not the point. The standing still was the point, and the mailboxes were only an excuse the neighbors would accept.
The neighbors who watched me work
That is the part nobody warns you about. On a strange street you are a tourist, which is a role people understand and mostly tolerate. On your own street you are a man everyone knows, standing in the road at seven in the morning aiming a camera at a fence, and there is no role for that at all.
The first week I explained myself constantly. I would hear a screen door and start talking before anyone had asked. By the third week I had learned to just say good morning and keep working, and by the second month people had rewritten me. I became the neighbor who does that. Someone left a note asking whether I would photograph a dogwood before it came down. A woman two houses along told me the story of the low brick wall at the corner, which was apparently a garden bed for thirty years before anyone thought to fill it in, and after she told me that I could not photograph the wall the same way again. It had a past tense now.
Photographing where you live means every picture arrives with a mortgage of information attached. You cannot see the wall purely. I spent a while thinking that was a handicap and I have stopped thinking so. It is simply a different picture than the stranger would make, and the difference is the whole reason to do it.
The weather is the only thing that changes
A street like mine does not do much. Over fifteen years the physical changes could be listed on a note card: two roofs, one fence, a tree, a driveway resurfaced, a family in and a family out. Everything else that happens on the street is light and water and season, arriving and leaving on a cycle that pretends to repeat and does not quite.
So the work became a study of the same twelve or fifteen subjects under conditions I do not control. The oak at the end has been photographed by me in fog, in the flat white overcast that this part of Tennessee produces for weeks at a time, in the hard slanting light of a January afternoon, and once in the strange bronze air before a storm when everything looked lit from underneath. Same tree. Same standing spot, more or less. The pictures are not variations on a theme. They are closer to different subjects that happen to share a shape.
I understand now why this is the oldest idea in the practice. It is not about the tree. It is about proving to yourself, frame by frame, that the world is not the fixed sketch your head is holding.
The house that came down
In the second year of doing this, the small house near the corner came down. It had been empty a long time. I had photographed it perhaps thirty times without any sense of urgency, mostly the porch, once the back of it through a gap in the privet. Then the machines came on a Tuesday and by Thursday there was dirt.
I did not photograph the demolition. I stood and watched it and decided not to, and I still do not fully understand why, except that lifting the camera would have turned a loss into a subject and I was not ready to do that to a house I had walked past every day. What I did instead was go back to the thirty frames I already had, which had been made carelessly, out of habit, on my way to somewhere else.
They are not good photographs. They are the only ones that exist. That is the lesson the street handed me and it was not a gentle one: the archive is built out of the frames you make when nothing seems to be happening, because you do not get advance notice of which ordinary Tuesday was the last one.
What fifteen years finally gave me
I am four years into photographing this street now, nineteen years into living on it, and I have maybe a dozen pictures I would show anyone. That is a terrible ratio by any sensible measure and I do not care about it much. The work has done something else instead.
It has made the walk from my door to the corner unpredictable again. That is the return, and I did not expect it to be the return. I go outside and I do not know what the hedge is doing, or where the shadow of the utility pole has moved to this month, or whether the puddle at the low spot in the road will be there. I have to go and look. After fifteen years of certainty about four hundred feet of asphalt, I have argued my way back into not knowing, which is the only condition in which I have ever made anything worth keeping.
And there is a smaller thing underneath it. I like the street more. Not in a sentimental way, not because it is beautiful, because it is largely not. I like it the way you come to like a person after you have listened to them longer than politeness required. The camera was the excuse for the listening. It usually is.