An hour a week with someone else’s eyes
I photograph a few hours a week. I look at other people’s photographs for considerably longer than that, and for a long time I did not count any of it as part of the practice. It felt like leisure, or worse, like avoidance — the thing I did instead of going outside.
I have changed my mind. Looking is at least half of the work, maybe more. But how you look turns out to matter enormously, and most of the looking I did for my first several years was actively making me worse.
The library book I keep renewing
The branch here is small and its photography section is one shelf, most of it landscape calendars and a few technique manuals from before I was born. But there is one monograph on that shelf, a survey of American work from the middle of the last century, and I have checked it out probably fifteen times.
The reason I keep going back is that a printed book makes me slow down in a way nothing on a screen has ever managed. There are around ninety plates in it. I cannot skip ahead meaningfully, because turning pages is physical and the sequence is fixed. There is one photograph at a time and it is a fixed size and it is not going to move or be replaced by another one in half a second.
What that does to me is force a kind of stubbornness. On the fifth or sixth pass I started noticing things I had looked straight through: how often the maker put the main subject well off to one side, how much empty ground is in the bottom of those frames, how consistently the horizon sits low. Not one of those observations arrived on the first viewing, or the second. They arrived because a book made it inconvenient to move on.
Scrolling, and what it does to me
I am not going to pretend I do not scroll. I do, most evenings, and I have paid attention to what it does.
The first thing is speed. I give a photograph something like a second, and in a second I can only register whether it is impressive. Not whether it is true, not whether it is interesting, not whether it is doing anything I have not seen. Impressive is the only quality that survives at that pace, and impressive is the least useful thing a photograph can be.
The second thing is that a fast feed teaches me to want a certain kind of frame. Bold color, obvious subject, strong shape, immediate hook. Those are the traits that win at one second per picture. After a heavy scrolling week I have caught myself out on the sidewalk hunting for exactly that, and skipping right past the quiet, slightly awkward things that are the only reason I photograph this town at all.
So I have not quit, but I have put a rule around it: no scrolling in the hour before I go out. That sounds superstitious and it is completely reliable. My worst walks follow my longest scrolls.
Learning to look slowly
The one deliberate exercise I do is simple and it has been the single most valuable thing in this whole essay. I pick one photograph, by anyone, and I sit with it for ten minutes.
Ten minutes is much longer than it sounds. The first minute is just the impression. The second and third minutes I usually spend restless, wanting to be done. Somewhere around minute four I start actually working: where does my eye enter, where does it get stuck, what is in the corners, what did the maker choose to leave out, where were they standing, how high were they holding the camera, what happened one second before.
That last question has taught me more than anything. Reconstructing the moment before the shutter tells you what the photographer knew and what they were waiting for. Sometimes you conclude they were lucky. More often you conclude they had been standing there a while, watching a situation they understood, and the picture is the last two seconds of a much longer act of attention. That reframes what I am trying to do when I am out working. I stopped thinking of good photographs as things people find and started thinking of them as things people wait out.
Copying, and where it stops being useful
I went through a period of copying openly. I found a photographer whose work I could not stop looking at, and for about three months I tried to make their pictures on my street.
It was useful for exactly one thing: it taught me their decisions from the inside. When you try to reproduce a way of framing, you discover very fast which parts are style and which parts are consequence. I learned that a certain flat, straight-on approach I admired requires standing much farther back than feels natural, and that the calm in those pictures comes almost entirely from the camera being level, which is boring and difficult and nothing to do with taste.
It stopped being useful the moment I noticed I was choosing subjects because they resembled the other person’s subjects. My town does not look like theirs. Forcing the resemblance meant walking past everything that is actually here in favor of things that could be mistaken for somewhere else. That is a dead end, and I could feel it going dead about two months before I admitted it.
What I kept was the level camera, which I still do, and which is not theirs anymore. That is how influence is supposed to work, I think. You take the mechanics and you leave the subjects alone.
The small show above a coffee counter
Twice a year the coffee place on the square hangs somebody’s work on the back wall. It is usually local, usually not very good in the way the books are good, and I go every time.
Seeing photographs on a wall, printed, at a size somebody chose, in a room where people are talking about something else entirely, is a completely different experience from seeing them anywhere else. A print has a scale and a surface and a physical presence, and about half of what I see online would simply collapse at that scale. It is a hard test and it is a fair one.
The last show was a woman who had photographed the same stretch of two-lane road over several years. Some of the frames were repetitive and a couple were badly printed. It did not matter. Standing in a room with thirty pictures of one road, made by someone who lives on it, was more instructive than any monograph, because I could see the whole shape of the project including its weak parts. Books only ever show you the finished, edited, best-of version of a practice. It is easy to conclude from books that other photographers do not make bad pictures. A small show on a coffee shop wall corrects that immediately, and it is a relief.
What I take back to my own street
The risk in all this looking is obvious. You can spend so much time inside other people’s vision that you lose the thread of your own, and I have had months where that happened. The symptom is always the same: I go out and everything I see reminds me of a photograph I have already seen, and I make nothing.
What keeps it useful is a fairly narrow question I try to bring to every book, every wall, every feed. Not what did they photograph, which will always be somewhere I am not. Instead: what were they paying attention to that I am not paying attention to?
Sometimes the answer is small and immediately usable. Someone was paying attention to the bottoms of frames; I now check mine. Someone was paying attention to the moment after the main event, when everybody relaxes; I have made three photographs I like since noticing that. Someone was paying attention to people’s hands.
Those transfer. The subjects do not, and should not. Nobody else is going to photograph this square, this water tower, this crossing where the bells go off at hours that make no sense. That part is only mine, and the whole reason to spend an hour a week with somebody else’s eyes is to come back and see mine more clearly.