The bend in the creek I keep coming back to
There is a place about eleven minutes from my front door where a small creek turns hard to the left under a pair of leaning box elders. It is not beautiful, exactly. There is a storm drain, and a length of orange plastic fencing that somebody put up during a sewer project four years ago and never took down. In spring the water runs the color of coffee with too much cream in it. In August it is barely water at all, just a wet seam in the mud with a few pools holding on.
I photographed that bend once a week, more or less, for a year. Not because it deserved it. Because I had run out of ideas and I wanted to see what would happen if I stopped looking for a subject and just accepted one.
What follows is what I learned, which is not the same as what I expected to learn.
Why I chose something ordinary on purpose
I had been going through a stretch where every photograph I made felt like it was reaching. I would drive somewhere for the light, or wait for a particular kind of weather, or plan a trip around the idea that a place I had never been would give me something the places I knew would not. Some of that is fair. Travel does shake you loose. But I was starting to notice that the photographs I actually liked, the ones I kept coming back to on the screen, were almost never the ones I had planned.
So I picked the creek because I had no feelings about it. I had walked past it a hundred times without stopping. If I had picked somewhere I already loved, I would have spent the year trying to prove I was right to love it, and that is a different and much worse project.
The rule I gave myself was simple. Once a week, at least twenty minutes, at any hour, in any weather, with whatever I happened to be carrying. I could not skip a week for reasons of light or mood. I could skip a week for reasons of life, and I did, six or seven times over the year, but I had to go the next day if I skipped.
The first two months were embarrassing
I want to be honest about this because I think the honest part is the useful part. My early frames were terrible in a very specific way. They were descriptive. Here is the creek. Here is the bend. Here is a wide view that contains all the available information and none of the interest. I was making the visual equivalent of a police report.
The problem was that I was still photographing the place as a whole, as if my job were to represent it. And a place, taken whole, is almost never a photograph. It is too much. The eye moves around it happily in life and finds nothing to hold on to in a frame.
Around week nine something shifted, and it shifted because I got bored. Boredom is underrated. When you have already made the obvious picture eight times, you stop making it, not out of discipline but out of fatigue. I started photographing smaller. A rusted bolt in a concrete lip. The way the orange fencing had gone brittle and pale on the south side and stayed bright on the north. A single sycamore leaf that had been sitting in the same eddy for three weeks, slowly turning to lace.
What repetition actually teaches
The standard thing people say about photographing one place over time is that you learn its light. That is true and it is also the least of it.
Yes, I learned that in October the sun comes through the gap in the treeline at about ten past five and puts a bar of warm light across the far bank for maybe eleven minutes. I learned that the mornings after a hard rain are useless because everything is uniformly gray and the water is opaque. I learned that the worst-sounding conditions, a flat white overcast in February, are actually the best for the small stuff, because nothing has a shadow to hide in.
But the deeper thing was that I stopped seeing the place as a place and started seeing it as a set of relationships. Water to bank. Old growth to new. Human leftovers to the slow work of everything else. Once you have seen the same bank in forty different states, you are no longer photographing a bank. You are photographing a moment in a process you now understand.
That understanding does not show up in any single frame. It shows up in the choices you make. You know which direction to face without thinking. You know that the thing that looks promising today looked promising in March and did not work, so you walk past it. It is an accumulated fluency, and it is invisible in the pictures the way an accent is invisible on the page.
The pictures I did not expect
Three photographs from that year still matter to me, and none of them are of the creek.
One is of a kid, maybe twelve, standing on the concrete lip with his shoes in one hand, absolutely still, looking down into the water with an expression I would call scientific. He was there in June. I had been going for five months and had never seen another human being at that spot. I got one frame before he noticed me, and then we both said hello and he told me there were crawfish under the flat rock, which there were.
The second is of the shadow of the fencing on the dry mud in September, the diamond pattern stretched into something that looks like a fishing net. I had walked past that shadow every week for a year and never once thought of it as a subject. In September the water was low enough that the mudflat was exposed and flat and lit, and suddenly it was the only thing there.
The third is just the leaf. The one in the eddy. By the time I made the frame I liked, it was almost entirely gone, a skeleton of veins the color of old paper, and I had watched it happen. That is not something you can find in an afternoon. It is only available to somebody who was already there, on purpose, doing something that felt pointless at the time.
What it did to the rest of my photography
The most useful effect was not on those pictures at all. It was on everything else.
I got much slower in unfamiliar places. That sounds like a loss and it is not. Before the creek year, arriving somewhere new made me anxious to gather, to cover, to not miss anything. Now, when I get somewhere I do not know, my instinct is to pick a corner and stay in it. I will give a single block an hour. I do not feel like I am missing the rest of the city, because I no longer believe there is a version of me who could have photographed the rest of the city well in that hour anyway.
I also stopped believing that a subject has to be interesting before you point a camera at it. Interest is not a property of the thing. It is something that develops between you and the thing, over time, and the camera is one of the tools that develops it. The creek was not interesting in January. It was interesting in September because I had done nine months of looking at it.
Here is the part I find hardest to explain. There were weeks when I drove over there in the dark after work, stood in the cold for twenty minutes, made four exposures I knew were bad, and drove home. Those weeks were not wasted, but they also were not enjoyable, and I do not want to dress them up as some kind of meditative practice. They were a chore I had assigned myself. The value came out at the end, all at once, in the form of a way of seeing I did not have before. If somebody had told me in month two that this was how it would work, I am not sure I would have believed them.
If you want to try it
A few things I would tell somebody starting their own version, and then I will stop giving advice, because this is a journal and not a manual.
- Pick somewhere close enough that going there is never a decision. Eleven minutes was right. Forty would have killed it by March.
- Pick somewhere you feel nothing about. Affection makes you sentimental and sentimentality makes you lazy.
- Do not set a goal for the work. I never intended a series, a book, a show. The moment it becomes a deliverable you start editing while you shoot, and editing while you shoot is how you make the same picture forty times.
The creek is still there. The orange fencing finally came down in the spring, and I felt something about that which I have not entirely worked out yet. I go back every couple of months now, not on a schedule. It looks completely different to me than it did the first afternoon, and nothing about it has changed.