What a Photograph Cannot Hold

The list of everything missing

A photograph of my kitchen table this morning contains the table, a cup, a folded newspaper, and the particular gray light that this town gets in February. It does not contain the fact that the house was cold, that I had slept badly, that a truck was idling outside, that the coffee was too strong, that I was thinking about a phone call I needed to make and did not want to. It does not contain the ten minutes before or the ten minutes after. It does not contain what the room smelled like, which was the single most present thing in the room.

I have been making photographs for a long time and I still occasionally forget how little they hold. The picture is so convincing that it passes itself off as a record of a moment when it is a record of a rectangle of reflected light lasting a fraction of a second. Almost everything that made the moment a moment is not in there.

Sound, smell, and the temperature of a room

Start with the obvious losses, because they are worse than we admit. Photography takes one sense out of five and throws away the rest, and the ones it throws away are frequently the ones doing the heavy lifting.

I photographed a hardware store aisle once and thought I had something. Looking at the frame later I could not understand why it felt so thin, and it took me a week to work out that the reason I had stopped in that aisle at all was the smell of cut lumber and machine oil, which had put me somewhere in about 1987 in a building three hundred miles from here. None of that is transmissible. A viewer gets shelves.

Same with temperature. A picture of a person on a porch in July and a picture of a person on a porch in January can look nearly identical, and the experience of standing on those two porches has nothing in common. We paper over this with visual codes, breath in the air, sweat, the quality of light, but those are hints, not the thing. The body knows something the frame cannot carry.

The minutes on either side

The heavier loss is time. A photograph cuts one slice out of a continuous thing and presents it as if the slice were self-contained, and it is not, and the viewer has no way to know what has been amputated.

Two people in a frame appear to be in the middle of something warm. Thirty seconds earlier they were arguing. Or a street looks empty and desolate and forty people walked through it in the minute before I pressed the shutter, and I waited them out on purpose, which means I manufactured the desolation and then presented it as a finding. I have done this. Every landscape photographer has done this. It is not exactly dishonest but it is worth being clear-eyed about, because the picture will not disclose it and I am usually the only person who knows.

The cruelty of the slice runs the other way too. There are frames in my archive where everyone looks fine and I know what happened the following spring, and the photograph carries none of that and cannot be made to. It sits there being cheerful. The information that would change everything about how you read it is simply not available in the file.

Motive and interior weather

Then there is the largest absence of all, which is the inside of anyone’s head. This is the one that separates photography from writing, and it is the reason I keep coming back to it despite everything, but it is a genuine limit and not a stylistic preference.

A picture can show me that a man on a bench has his hands folded and his eyes low. It cannot tell me whether he is grieving, resting, waiting for a bus, or thinking about lunch. All four look identical. What the photograph offers is a face and a posture, and what we do with them is project, instantly and confidently and usually wrongly. Every emotionally powerful photograph I have ever loved is a picture I filled in myself. The photographer supplied a shape and I supplied the feeling and then credited them for it.

This is why I have grown suspicious of my own reactions to strong images, my own included. When a frame moves me, part of what is moving me is my own material, brought to the table and laid over a stranger’s face.

What the frame edits out

Everything I have described so far is a limit of the medium. This next one is a limit of me, and it is less forgivable.

Four edges. Every photograph is a claim that what is inside the rectangle is the relevant part, and that claim is made by a person with opinions, standing in a particular spot, at a particular height, in a particular mood. Six inches to the left and there would be a dumpster in the corner. Turn ninety degrees and the quiet field is across the road from a highway. I choose, constantly, and the choosing is invisible in the result.

I try to keep this in front of me when I look at other people’s work and especially when I look at my own from a few years back. The question is not only what is in the picture. It is what was standing just outside it, and why I decided that thing was not part of the story.

Why the failure is the point

For a while all of this bothered me enough to be a small crisis. If the photograph cannot hold the smell, the temperature, the minutes on either side, the reason, the context, or the reality outside the frame, then what exactly am I collecting?

The answer I have arrived at is that the emptiness is the mechanism. A photograph is not a container of experience, it is a prompt for one. It works precisely because it is missing so much. All those absences are the spaces a viewer walks into. A frame that somehow contained everything would leave nobody anything to do, and I suspect it would be unbearable to look at for longer than a second.

The pictures in my life that have lasted are not the complete ones. They are the ones with a gap in them exactly the right size and shape for a person to stand in.

Making peace with a partial record

What this has changed, practically, is that I have stopped trying to make photographs do a job they are structurally unable to do. I no longer stand in a place trying to capture how it feels. That is not on offer. What is on offer is a small, precise, partial description that might, later, under the right conditions, cause a feeling in someone.

I also write more. A few lines in a notebook, the date, what the air was doing, why I stopped walking. Not for publication and not as a caption. It is a separate record that holds different things, and between the two of them I get closer to the actual afternoon than either one manages alone. The photograph handles the shapes. The notebook handles the smell and the reason.

And I have gotten more relaxed about the frames that fail. Of course they fail. They are asked to carry a whole world across a gap, using nothing but light, and they arrive with almost none of it. That any of them arrive with anything at all still seems to me like an unreasonable piece of luck.