The hardest subject is the one at the kitchen table
I can walk up to a stranger on a sidewalk, explain myself in two sentences, and make a portrait I am reasonably happy with. I have done it hundreds of times. I know what to say and I know when to stop.
I cannot reliably photograph my own mother.
This has bothered me for years, and I have finally spent enough time thinking about it to have something more useful than the observation itself. Photographing people you know is a genuinely different problem from photographing people you do not, and almost none of the skills transfer. Some of them actively get in the way.
Why it is harder, not easier
The obvious assumption is that familiarity should help. You have access. You have time. Nobody is going to say no or walk away.
But all three of those advantages have a cost.
Access means there is no urgency, and urgency is a lot of what makes you look carefully. When I have four minutes with a stranger I see everything. When I have unlimited afternoons with my brother, I see nothing, because there will always be another afternoon. The best picture of him I ever made was on a day he was leaving for a long time, which is not a coincidence.
Time means you never commit. With a stranger you make the picture now or you do not make it. At home I look at my wife reading in a particular slant of light and think, that is beautiful, I should get the camera, and by the time I have decided whether to interrupt her, she has turned the page and moved her head and it is gone. I have lost more pictures to deliberation in my own living room than to anything else, anywhere.
And the absence of refusal is not the same as consent. A stranger says yes or no cleanly. Somebody who loves you will say yes when they mean no, because saying no would be a small unkindness and you have been asking a lot lately. That is a much harder thing to read and a much easier thing to abuse without noticing.
The knowing gets in the way of the seeing
Here is the deeper problem, and it took me a long time to name it.
When I photograph a stranger, I am working entirely from what is in front of me, because that is all I have. The way a shoulder drops. The set of a jaw. I read the visual information because I have no other information.
When I photograph my father, I am not seeing him at all. I am seeing forty years of him, layered over the actual man sitting in the chair. I know what his face means before it does anything. So I stop looking, and I make a picture of the person I already have in my head, and the picture comes out looking like a snapshot because that is exactly what it is: a confirmation, not an observation.
This produces a particular kind of failure that I now recognize instantly. The photograph is technically fine, everyone is in focus, and it is completely dead. It is dead because I was not curious. Curiosity is the actual engine, and it is very hard to be curious about somebody whose face you have known since before you could read.
What has actually helped
I have found a few things that work, and they are all variations on one idea: make yourself a stranger again for twenty minutes.
The first is to photograph people I know while they are doing something absorbing. Not posed, not candid exactly, but occupied. My father repairing something. A friend cooking. When somebody is genuinely engaged in a task, the face they show you is not the one they have for you. It is the face they have for the work, and I have usually never seen it, even after decades. That is the crack the picture gets through.
The second is to photograph the periphery. Hands. The back of a head. Somebody halfway out of the frame. This sounds like a dodge and for a while it was, but I have come to think it is legitimate. I know my mother’s face too well to see it. I do not know her hands. When I printed a frame of her hands on the arm of a chair, I found I had made something about age and habit and a lifetime of specific work that I could never have made by pointing the camera at her face.
The third is to declare the session. Sitting somebody down and saying “I want to make a portrait of you” is uncomfortable with family in a way it is not with strangers, and it is worth pushing through. It changes the frame from an intrusion into an agreement. Everybody knows what is happening. They can put their coffee down. And crucially, I stop feeling like a thief in my own house, which was a background hum I had not noticed until it stopped.
The intrusion problem
I have to write about this honestly because it is the part I got wrong for years.
There was a stretch where I photographed constantly at home. Every dinner, every ordinary Tuesday, and I told myself I was documenting our life, which was true and was also a rationalization. What was actually happening is that my family was being observed all the time by somebody they could not ask to stop without it becoming a conversation about my hobby.
My wife said something to me one evening, gently, that I have not forgotten. She said that sometimes she wanted to just be in the room. Not be in a picture of the room. Be in it.
I put the camera away for about six weeks after that, and when I came back to it I came back differently. I now photograph at home much less and much more deliberately. I ask more. I put it down when the answer is a hesitation. And the pictures got better, not worse, because a person who is not being constantly surveilled will actually give you something when you finally do ask.
The thing nobody tells you is that access is a resource you can spend. Every picture you take of somebody who did not particularly want to be photographed makes the next one slightly harder to get. I burned a lot of that early on for frames that were not worth it.
What these pictures are for
There is one more thing that makes photographing people you know different, and it is not about technique at all.
These photographs have a second job. A picture of a stranger is a picture, and it succeeds or fails as one. A picture of my grandmother in her kitchen is a picture and it is also, eventually, going to be the only way anybody sees her stand in that kitchen. That second job does not care whether the composition is good.
I have made peace with the fact that some of the family photographs I value most are, by any standard I would apply to my other work, mediocre. Slightly soft, badly framed, flash going off in a dim room. They are indispensable anyway. And some of my most competent, best-lit portraits of family are worthless to me because I was thinking about photography when I made them instead of about the person.
That has made me a lot more relaxed at home. If the frame is going to matter for reasons other than its quality, then the pressure to make it good comes off, and paradoxically I take better ones. The evening I stopped trying to make a portrait of my daughter and just started keeping the camera nearby, I got three frames in a week that I would not trade for anything in my archive.
Still working on it
I have not solved this. Last month I spent an afternoon trying to photograph my brother in his workshop and came away with forty frames of a man politely enduring his sibling. Every one of them is a picture of our relationship at that moment, which was: he was busy and I was in the way.
What I keep returning to is that the difficulty is not a technical problem to be solved but a permanent condition of the work. You cannot un-know somebody. You can only find angles of approach that let the knowing sit off to the side for a few minutes, and the angles are different for every person, and they change.
I am going back next month. He is rebuilding a chest of drawers and he does not mind if I sit in the corner and stay quiet. That is probably the whole method: earn the corner, stay quiet, and wait until you forget for a moment that you already know how this face works.